This week, I’m back with Magical Meals and a Movie, this time featuring The Little Mermaid. Today’s recipe fits the theme perfectly! These Nilla Wafer “Oyster” Cookies are so simple and delicious! They are kid-approved and perfect for an under the sea or mermaid themed party. These cookies only require a few ingredients- let’s get into it!
Start out by preparing the frosting. For this recipe, I used my cream cheese buttercream frosting recipe. You can also use your favorite store-bought frosting. To the frosting, add food coloring of your preferred color.
To one nilla wafer, spread frosting across the cookie and then add another nilla wafer cookie on top to make a sandwich.
Roll each cookie in the candy pearls. These are the candy pearls that I used– they worked perfectly!
Serve these Nilla Wafer “Oyster” Cookies and enjoy!
Pin this recipe for later and be sure to follow me on social media so that you never miss a recipe!
-Ashton
Nilla Wafer “Oyster” Cookies
Ingredients
Method
- Prepare the cream cheese buttercream frosting according to the recipe or use your favorite store-bought frosting. To the frosting, add food coloring of your preferred color.
- To one nilla wafer, spread frosting across the cookie and then add another nilla wafer cookie on top to make a sandwich.
- Roll each cookie in the candy pearls.
- Enjoy!
Disclosure: some of the links on this website are affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, I may earn a referral commission.
Hi, I’m Ashton — a Disney-loving, food-obsessed single mom of two amazing boys! I’m the creator behind The Haunted Foodie and now the proud author of Magical Meals and a Movie: The Cookbook. My e-book combines over 70 original recipes, printable menu cards, crafts, activities, and decorating tips to turn family movie nights into magical memories. Whether I’m in the kitchen, planning festive movie nights, or dreaming of my next Disney trip, I’m all about creating joy through food and storytelling. I’m so excited you’re here to share the magic with me! 💜
Leave a Reply